Introduction 1
1. Empiricist Causal Thinking 3
Empirical Objectivity 4
Operationalized Concepts 5
Facts 6
Theorizing 7
Explanation 10
Questioning Empiricism 13
Ducks, Rabbits, and Paradigms 14
Alternative Facts 16
Relativism 17
2. Interpretation and Understanding Meaning 18
Constitutive Meaning 19
Subjective Meaning 20
Use in Practice 22
Intersubjective Meaning 23
Participant Know-How 27
Relation Between Subjective and Intersubjective Meanings 28
Comparison and Limits 30
Empathy and Conversation 31
Comparison with Empiricism 34
Tree Work 36
Questioning Interpretive Inquiry 42
3. Critical Theory: Structural Violence and the Critique of Ideology 45
Structural Violence 46
Comparison with Empiricist Causal Analysis 47
Structures and Injustice 49
Structures of Justice 50
Ideology 52
The Critique of Ideology 53
Everyday Political Ideology 54
Liberal Democratic Capitalism 56
Critical Race Theory and Affirmative Action 58
Is Critical Theory Tyrannical? 60
Critical Theory and Psychoanalysis 61
Relation to Interpretive Analysis 63
Structural Change and Opposition 64
Politics and Political Analysis 66
4. Discourse Analysis The Genealogical Study of Discursive Power 68
Discourses 69
Values 71
Knowledges 72
Procedures and Methods 73
Truths and Truth Power 73
Disciplining Mechanisms 76
Subjectivities, Subjects, and Discursive Violence 77
Deconstruction 80
Politics of Discourse Analysis 81
Power 82
Comparison with Other Approaches 84
Controversy Over Political Analysis 86
5. Postcolonial Subaltern Studies and Decolonizing Political Analysis 90
The Subaltern 91
Paradigmatic Examples 92
Teaching in Political Analysis 94
Avoiding Imposition 95
Catachrestic Analysis 96
Contemporary Immigration Politics and the Subaltern 97
September 2021 at the Border 99
Identifying and Reconstructing the Discursive Erasure 100
Dwelling Within and Re-narrating Events from the Erasure 104
Attuning to Traces of Subaltern Voices 104
Examining the Colonial Conditions of Erasure 109
Receiving Subaltern Teachings in the Silence of the Erasure 112
Comparison with Other Approaches 114
Conclusion 120
Index 123
|
|