Introduction
1. Empiricism
Introduction
Empirical Observation, Positivism, and the Unity of Science
Legitimate Knowledge, Data, Operational Definitions, Facts,
Causes, Correlations, Variables, and Explanation
The Deductive-Nomological Model as the Analytical Imperative
of Empiricism
The Importance of the Deductive-Nomological Model
The Dominance, Appeal, Prestige, and Legitimacy of Empiricist
Social Science
Study Questions
2. Internal Tensions: From Empiricism to Hermeneutics
Introduction
Critical Scrutiny of Empiricism
Expectations of the Familiar and Unfamiliar
Underdetermination and the Duck-Rabbit Example
Paradigms
Theory-posited facts, Rival Theories, and the Spectre of
Relativism
The Essence of the Critique
The Bridge to Hermeneutical (or Interpretive) Inquiry
Study Questions
3. Hermeneutics: Subjective and Intersubjective Approaches to the
Study of Meaning
Introduction
The Hermeneutical Meaning of ‘Constitute’
The Hermeneutical Turn I: Action and Subjectivity
Historical Interpretive Analysis: Three Dimensions of Context
Examples of Verstehen Inquiry
Subjectivity and the Social
Unintended Consequences and Reification
The Empiricist Response to the Problem of Society: Social Facts
The Hermeneutical Turn II: Practices & Intersubjective Meanings
The Concept of Intersubjectivity
Is Everything Subjective? On the Relation between Subjective
and Intersubjective Meanings
Conversational Inquiry
Going General
Going Local
Languages of Perspicuous Contrast
Examples of Conversational Inquiry
Criteria for Understanding
Limits and Questions
Study Questions
4. Scientific Realism and Critical Theory: Structure, Ideology, and
Emancipation
Introduction
Realism and Empiricism: Real Causal Mechanisms
Causal Mechanisms in the Social World
Examples of Structural Causality
Structures and Social Change
Ideational Structures
Marxian Realism
The Realist Model of Interpreting Politics
Contemporary Critical Theory
Knowledge and Human Interests
Empiricism and the Human Interest in Technical Control
Hermeneutics and the Interest in Action-Orienting Mutual
Understanding
Autonomy, Responsibility, and Critical Social Science
The Critique of Ideology in Social Science Research
Inapplicable but Not Inoperative
The Critique of Ideology and Political Life: Structural Violence
Structural Violence: Sanctions or War
“Deadly Silences” and Critical Race Theory
Goals of Critical Theory
Study Questions
5. Discourse Analysis
Introduction
Discourse, Constituted Subjects and Subjectivities, Disciplinary
Mechanisms
Different Subjectivities
Normalizing, Homogenizing, Domesticating, Totalizing,
Colonizing, Hegemonic Power
Discursive Violence: Discipline and the Production of Desire
Discourse, Power, and Change
Productive Power and Precautions
Genealogical Analysis of Discourse, the Resurgence of Subjugated
Ways of Life, and Possibilities for Creative Resistance
Foucault and Resistance
Example I: Desiring Fascism: The Modern Nation-State,
Governmentality, and Biopolitics
Example II: A Brief Genealogical Analysis of Discourses of Speaking
and Listening
Discourse, Freedom, and the Individual-as-Subject
Conclusion: Discourse Analysis in Comparative Perspective
Study Questions
6. Postcolonial and Subaltern Inquiry
Introduction: Colonial Violence, Past and Present
Postcolonialism: Basic Terms and the Postcolonial ‘Prerogative’
Colonial Power: Contradiction and Ambivalence
Colonial Knowledge: Orientalism and Colonial Violence
The Psychic Dynamics of Colonial Violence
Mimicry and the Boundaries between Colonizer and Colonized
Fanon on Colonial Violence in Algeria and Postcolonial Analysis
as Psychoanalysis
Anti-Colonialism and Mimicry
Cautions Concerning Objectivist and de-Politicized
Psychoanalysis
Postcolonial Critique, an Example: The Coloniality of Western
Immigration Management
Subalternity: Discursive Erasure and The Subaltern
“Can the Subaltern Speak?”
The Subaltern and Ideology
Subaltern Representation as Teaching
Writing and the Metaphysics of Presence
Difference in Repetition
Deconstruction and the Subaltern
Justice
Catachrestic Model of Postcolonial-Subaltern Inquiry
Identifying, Reconstructing, and Inhabiting Colonial
Erasure
Tracing Subaltern Traces and Teachings
Renarrating and Rewriting Erased Lifeworlds and
Experiences
In the Eye of the Sun
Signating Signs Beyond Subalternity
Implications for Interpreting Politics
Study Questions
7. Conclusion: Openings
Readings for Interpreting Politics
Index